172-User Test Shows Crowdsourced Clicks Left Google Photo Carousels Unchanged
Local SEO theory holds that Google orders Google Business Profile (GBP) photo carousels by user engagement, placing the most-viewed image at the front.
Darren Shaw reports running a research project with Miriam Ellis via a mailing list and social posts to test whether crowdsourced engagement could push a target image to the front of a carousel.
Directing 172 participants to view, click, and share specific photos across restaurant profiles left the photo carousels unchanged.
Conversely, requesting customer photos alongside review requests places user-submitted images where they tend to stick at the top of the profile's review section.
For search visibility, Google AI parses image contents and surfaces different profile photos to match query intent.
Uploading a full set of photos across every product and service line gives the system intent-matched assets to pull — as seen on the profile for Mike Blumenthal's client Barbara Oliver, where searches for "engagement rings" surface an engagement ring photo while searches for "necklaces" return necklaces.